A departing compliance officer’s qualifications can be rebuilt in months; the judgment and regulator relationships that leave with them take years. CCI contributing writer Trevor Treharne reports on a knowledge drain that Asia-Pacific regulators are now naming outright, with a complication few saw coming: As AI takes over the routine work that once trained juniors into seniors, the experts he interviews warn that companies may be automating away their future compliance leaders.
Eamonn Cunningham spent 30 years building the risk management function at Westfield, later Scentre Group, one of the world’s largest retail property and shopping mall operators in the APAC region, before retiring as its chief risk officer in 2016. He made sure almost none of what he’d learned left with him.
“On my retirement, very little knowledge walked out the door with me that had not been previously transferred over or already embedded in the system,” he told CCI in a recent interview.
But that’s not the norm, said Cunningham, who believes that far fewer departures in the region get that kind of deliberate handover.
A rebuild can take years when a proper handover doesn’t happen, said May May Lim, managing director of the International Compliance Association (ICA) APAC. Lim puts it at 18-36 months, even for a company that starts early. The loss of institutional memory isn’t confined to the region, or to companies. The US Securities and Exchange Commission lost about 18% of its staff in the fiscal year that ended in September 2025, according to a 2026 Government Accountability Office report. More than half of the SEC employees GAO interviewed said departing colleagues had taken unique knowledge or specialized skills with them.
In Asia-Pacific, that rebuild is complicated by how differently the region regulates. A 2025 Deloitte APAC report describes rising complexity and continued fragmentation in regulators’ approaches and priorities across the region. Its markets range from Australia, where a royal commission pushed banks to build compliance into how they operate, to economies still setting up compliance departments in the first place. Cost pressures are also playing a part in the problem. In a 2024 LexisNexis Risk Solutions study of financial institutions in five APAC markets, 81% said they were prioritizing cuts to compliance costs.
Hong Kong’s banking regulators spent the first quarter of 2025 surveying 147 banks about the skills they will need for the rest of the decade, and when the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, the Hong Kong Association of Banks and the Hong Kong Institute of Bankers published the results in August 2025, one of the gaps they flagged wasn’t a new technology or a new product line. It was compliance itself, with “new regulatory compliance” identified as one of the three key banking knowledge gaps expected to emerge over the coming years.
Singapore’s rules on nominee directors and beneficial ownership, which took effect in 2025 are another example of local regimes getting more detailed, not less. The compliance leaders interviewed for this piece, across law, executive search, industry associations and one retired chief risk officer, all point to the same underlying question: what happens when the one person who actually understands a given regime, and has the relationship to go with it, leaves.
What actually gets lost
Formal qualifications can be finished in months, Lim said. What takes years is judgment: “Knowing how a specific regulator actually behaves in practice, which gray areas get escalated versus handled quietly, and the informal relationships that make enforcement conversations go smoothly.” In the meantime, she said, companies lose institutional memory of past regulatory interactions, speed of decision-making and the regulator relationship itself: “Regulators in this region often deal with named individuals they trust, and that trust doesn’t automatically transfer with the title.”
Lim also pointed to where that gap is worst. Demand for ICA’s qualifications is growing fastest among fintechs and payment institutions navigating the Monetary Authority of Singapore’s licensing obligations, and among banks and corporates building anti-money laundering and financial crime capability across Southeast Asia, she said, which tracks closely with where the talent shortage is most severe. Interest is also rising from sectors outside financial services altogether, where she said the gap is “arguably even more acute because compliance capability was never built in-house to begin with.”
That framing isn’t universal. James A. Fanto, the Gerald Baylin Professor of Law and co-director of the Center for the Study of Business Law and Regulation at Brooklyn Law School, said a departure “shouldn’t matter so long as they have junior people in a separate department and train them adequately,” pointing to compliance training bodies as one mechanism for passing on the trade. But Fanto tied the risk directly to how developed a market’s compliance function already is. Asked why so little research exists on compliance knowledge loss specifically in Asia-Pacific, he said it depends on the market: “It is definitely well developed in Australia. Again, the more developed it is, the less concern one has with the departure of senior people because there should be a pipeline of others to take the task on.” The goal in thinner markets, he said, has to be building compliance departments in the first place, which means investment and “a raising of the status of compliance officers in the organizational hierarchy.”
The First Rung Matters More Than the Ladder
Can organizations preserve the pathways through which entry-level workers become experts in the time of AI?
Read moreDetailsWhy the gap keeps widening
Craig Williams, regional managing partner of Heidrick & Struggles’ corporate officers practice for Asia-Pacific and the Middle East, drew a similar line between markets that have already been tested by regulators and those that haven’t.
“There are two types of organizations: those that have been through intense regulatory scrutiny, and those that are going to,” he said. “The ones with the ‘battle scars’ understand regulatory intent at a much deeper level, because they have had to translate it into culture, behavior and controls.”
Australia, in the wake of its Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry and the remediation that followed, is Williams’ clearest example: “The knowledge stops being one person’s and becomes part of how the organization operates.” Where that scrutiny hasn’t happened yet, he said, “Judgment often sits with individual leaders rather than being embedded, so key-person risk is much greater.”
Williams also pointed to how this plays out at board level. Where directors carry personal accountability for governance failures, he said, succession has increasingly become a board-level priority, and “leading organizations are expected to have a clear view of their talent pipelines, key-person risks and succession plans for critical roles.” Less mature organizations, he said, may not have felt that pressure yet, but it will become harder to ignore as regulatory expectations keep rising. He described succession depth as requiring two parallel tracks, an internal pipeline and an active external map of available talent, a pattern he said first showed up in Asia-Pacific’s banks and is now playing out across insurance, wealth and asset management, superannuation and private credit.
A director at an industry association, who asked not to be named, pointed to a more immediate pressure working against succession planning: cost. Large financial institutions, the director said, generally have the size to build bench strength, but “in this climate of cost consciousness, many have to take on additional responsibilities, double, triple or quadruple hatting.” Smaller organizations often don’t have that flexibility at all, the director said. The industry is also losing senior anti-financial-crime practitioners to cost pressure and career exits, and some organizations are responding by hiring down. For example, a money laundering reporting officer role that would typically need 15 to 20 years of experience, the director said, may instead go to someone with under 10, “as they would not be as ‘expensive.’”
What a real handover looks like
Carrie Leung, CEO of the Hong Kong Institute of Bankers, in a written statement to Corporate Compliance Insights, said the answer, from the banking side, is to address the problem beyond simply looking to fill vacancies. “The challenge facing banks is not finding a replacement after a compliance professional leaves, but ensuring that critical knowledge and expertise are institutionalized before any transition occurs,” she said. The Hong Kong Institute of Bankers’ response includes its enhanced competency framework, endorsed by The Hong Kong Monetary Authority as a benchmark across specialized roles including compliance and anti-money laundering, and its certified banker program. She also pointed to a newer tool: “AI-powered knowledge management tools can act as effective ‘handover agents,’ helping preserve organizational knowledge, improve accessibility of information and reduce dependency on any single individual.”
Lim’s advice is more procedural: identify a successor early and give them real qualifications rather than ad hoc exposure, have that successor sit in on actual regulatory interactions while the departing officer can still sanity-check their judgment and document institutional knowledge, “past precedents, regulator relationships, informal understandings,” rather than leaving it in one person’s head. Waiting until after someone leaves, she said, means starting that rebuild from zero, “with no one left to correct early mistakes or vouch for the successor with the regulator.”
That planned, deliberate handover is exactly what Cunningham, who now operates a boutique risk management consultancy business, did himself. He treated it as an obligation rather than a luxury. “I have always worked on the principle that no one is indispensable and therefore you need to plan for when that person moves on,” he said.
His approach had two parts: building as much of his knowledge as possible into policies, procedures and systems, and a detailed, one-to-one handover, with an accompanying manual, covering every part of his role, including third-party relationships. Conversations with industry counterparts across Asia-Pacific, the Americas and Europe before his own retirement suggested that approach is closer to the exception than the rule, he said. Companies plan for unexpected departures to some degree, but the handover process itself is often left thin, with some organizations simply assuming “the successor will be pretty smart and he or she will just figure it out.” His own conclusion is a caution rather than a verdict: the more senior the departure, the greater the vulnerability to a knowledge gap, “particularly because of the lack of transfer of nuanced knowledge that would never find its way into a computer system.”
If AI does the junior work, who becomes senior?
Cunningham’s warning about knowledge that never reaches a computer system has a mirror image: AI is beginning to absorb the work that has traditionally turned junior staff into senior ones.
The director at the industry association had already noted organizations “choosing to fill gaps using technology.” Asked where the next generation of money-laundering reporting officers with 15 to 20 years of experience would come from, the director said the industry has started to ask the same thing. “This is an area that is under discussion and some senior leaders are already calling it out.” The director said the concerns center on identifying skills gaps and finding a way to bridge them; one half-joking answer is to “steal” experienced practitioners from the public sector. The director does not see an immediate fix: “[Anti-financial crime] roles will evolve, individuals will pick up new skills, and the ways of ‘becoming senior’ would also change.”
Lim thinks the shift could make the rebuild she described even longer. Much of the judgment a senior officer relies on, she said, starts with routine work: reviewing transactions flagged by monitoring systems, checking customers against sanctions lists and verifying who clients are and where their money comes from. Most of those cases turn out to be harmless. “But working through thousands of them is how people learn what normal looks like in their market, and how to spot the one case that isn’t,” she said. With AI now taking on much of that work, “tomorrow’s successors may therefore start the 18-month-to-three-year clock with less to build on,” she said, while regulators will still hold named individuals accountable.
Her answer is to create that exposure deliberately rather than leave it to chance. Juniors should check the AI’s decisions and explain why each one is right rather than simply approving them, she said. They should also be brought in much earlier on serious calls, such as whether to file a suspicious activity report, and into meetings with regulators, with a senior officer there to guide their judgment. “The organizations that handle this best will be training up a bench before they need to,” she said. “Those that don’t may find they have automated away their future compliance leaders.”
Leung said that while AI can increasingly take on routine tasks and support knowledge management, compliance professionals should embrace the technology and the changes it brings to their learning journey.
“By freeing compliance practitioners from more routine activities, AI can create greater capacity for continuous and comprehensive learning, enabling them to broaden their knowledge, strengthen professional judgment and progress towards becoming holistic bankers,” she said.
Formal training, documentation and frameworks can be measured and built on a timeline. The regulator relationship Lim described, and the embedded judgment Williams called a battle scar, cannot be handed over the same way, and if Lim is right, the routine work that once built that judgment is shrinking. That is the part still most likely to walk out the door.


Trevor Treharne is a contributing writer for Corporate Compliance Insights. He has also written for StrategicRISK and the Korea JoongAng Daily. 








