Backlash against Microsoft’s ham-handed rollout of its Recall app for some PC users was swift and well-earned. But privacy expert Scott Allendeveaux says that while Microsoft’s missteps were indeed dumb, the underlying tech in the app could present benefits to companies that can balance the privacy vs. functionality scales.
On initial review, Microsoft’s Recall rollout was stunningly boneheaded from a privacy perspective, but after a closer, multi-layered examination, the business strategy behind Recall becomes readily apparent — the software giant is attempting to inject artificial intelligence into virtually every aspect of our online life.
Recall was set to offer innovative capabilities for efficient information management and quick information retrieval, but it also posed major data privacy risks. Moreover, in an enterprise setting, the app has the very real potential of exposing sensitive proprietary data in a worst-case scenario, and these scenarios are becoming ever more common.
Recall’s functionality highlights the particular threat AI poses to our privacy rights. Microsoft’s initial decision to enable Recall to load by default without user consent was alarming and invasive. The subsequent changes to make it an opt-in situation reflect the importance of user autonomy and the need for constant vigilance in protecting digital privacy.
Total Recall?
The innovative app initially faced a wave of criticism for its invasive nature. The app was enabled on Microsoft Copilot-enabled PCs, capturing screenshots of desktop activity every few seconds. This constant data collection alarmed many users, who were unaware that such detailed information was being recorded without their explicit consent.
Privacy advocates and security experts were quick to label the feature as incredibly invasive, drawing comparisons to keylogger malware. Enterprise customers were immediately alarmed by an assortment of real threats the app posed.
The backlash prompted Microsoft to make significant changes, transitioning the feature to an opt-in model. This move aimed to respect user autonomy and address the privacy concerns that had been raised.
Following the controversy, a fundamental conclusion is that while cutting-edge technology like Recall can offer substantial benefits, it must be approached with extreme caution. Users need to be aware of the privacy risks involved and take proactive measures to protect every aspect of their digital content, be archived or created in real time. Microsoft and other tech companies must continue to listen to user feedback and prioritize privacy to ensure that innovation does not come at the expense of fundamental rights.
Minnesota Latest State to OK Consumer Data Privacy Law
Measure set to go into effect for most covered entities next summer
Read moreDetailsBalancing risk and reward
Recall undoubtedly offers several benefits that can enhance productivity and data management. Its ability to recover lost information, combined with advanced search functionalities and AI integration, makes it a valuable tool for users who frequently need to retrieve specific data quickly.
In professional settings, such as law firms, Recall can aid in time tracking, case management and evidence collection. These features can streamline workflows and improve efficiency. For computer coders, too, the ability to recall past work could hasten their ability to troubleshoot.
But the privacy risks that functionality brings are substantial. The app’s default setting to capture and store screenshots every few seconds means that sensitive information like financial banking details, personal communications, customer data and healthcare data could be inadvertently exposed. This poses a significant threat to user privacy, as any unauthorized access to this data could lead to severe consequences, including identity theft and serial data breaches.
Recall’s unveiling raised the collective eyebrows of regulators, particularly those that have been eagle-eyed for potential privacy breaches. UK’s information commissioner’s office has even reached out to Microsoft to understand the safeguards in place to protect user privacy.
Employee privacy lessons
Microsoft’s misstep notwithstanding, companies may consider technology like Recall, though they would be well-advised to take away several lessons, whether they’re using Recall or another, similar app, including:
- Opt-in policies: Establish a centralized corporate policy for the use of Recall or features like it, ensuring that the decision to opt in is made at the organizational level rather than left to individual employees. This allows the organization to assess the benefits and privacy risks comprehensively and ensures uniform application of data protection protocols.
- Risk assessment and compliance: Perform a detailed risk assessment to evaluate how such features align with your organization’s data protection policies and compliance obligations. Identify any risks related to capturing and storing sensitive information, and verify that the use of Recall or tools like it complies with industry regulations, potentially including GDPR, HIPAA or CCPA.
- Secure configuration and access control: Configure Recall-like tools with the most stringent security settings and restrict access based on specific job roles and responsibilities. Implement multi-factor authentication (MFA) and biometric authentication to safeguard against unauthorized access to captured data. Regularly audit access logs to track who is using such technology and how the data is being handled.
- Data minimization and retention policies: Define strict guidelines for data minimization and retention. Ensure that only essential data is captured and stored, and impose limits on how long screenshots or other information are retained. Periodically review and delete unnecessary data to minimize the risk of exposure in the event of a breach.
- Employee training and awareness: Offer comprehensive training to employees on correct usage, emphasizing the importance of data privacy and security. Educate staff on the potential risks associated with the feature and the corporate policies designed to mitigate those risks. Encourage responsible use of apps like Recall and vigilance regarding the type of information being captured.
- Monitoring and incident response: Establish continuous monitoring of usage within the organization. Develop a specific incident response plan for potential data breaches related to Recall, ensuring that your team can respond quickly to unauthorized access or data exposure
Microsoft’s after-the-fact decision to change Recall to opt-in functionality and implement additional security features shows the company takes privacy concerns seriously. If users take proactive measures to protect their data, the benefits might outweigh the risks, but constant vigilance will be necessary as AI innovation rolls on.
Scott Allendevaux, LP, CISSP, CIPP/US, HCISPP, CIPT, CIPM is senior practice lead at Allendevaux & Co., an Ohio-based cybersecurity agency. 
